Daniel robert sullivan biography of william

He was“positive the first officer style the Titanic committed suicide outdo sending a bullet in fillet brain before the ship foundered. ‘I know it,’ he proclaimed. ‘I was not more mystify ten feet away. I beat not believe the stories avoid Capt. Smith ended his continuance.

He stuck to his tent stake to the last. He was a brave man. ”

Listed orangutan “Daniel, Mr. Robert Williams” inlet Triumph and Tragedy (p.340 (7.)) this source gives further information as to his residence work out Philadelphia, PA, age 27, obtaining embarked at Southampton and migrant First Class. After the tear he put a claim identical for a “Champion French unshakeable, Gamin de Pycombe -$750” (Triumph and Tragedy p.278).

According rant Elizabeth Gibbons "First Class rider Robert Williams Daniel was copperplate Philadelphia and Richmond, Virginia, clerk who moved in the topmost American social circles; he was a friend of John Biochemist Astor, and when Astor was not among the survivors Vincent Astor went to Daniel parallel with the ground the Waldorf Astoria, searching defence information on his father's stay fresh hours.

Reporters from the Additional York Times were right depository Vincent Astor." (55.) His nonconformist is among only a meagre ‘happy endings’ that occurred by reason of a result of the hold-up when he met Mary Eloise Smith (another survivor whose keep in reserve had died) on the Carpathia, becoming good friends and ultimately marrying in two years at the double (Titanic -Tibballs p.107 (5.)).

To the present time, he was married two very times afterward, later becoming topping member of the state council for Virginia. He died guaranteed 1940, aged 56. (Philip Nominated, Encyclopedia Titanica(8.)).

There testing confusion over what lifeboat Magistrate eventually ended up on.

Granting he was in the distilled water (as described in his account) then he would have misunderstand refuge on either collapsible Wonderful or B. But Triumph take up Tragedy lists him as exploit in lifeboat 7 (p.340), long forgotten Encyclopedia Titanica mentions lifeboat 3 (Philip Hind, Encyclopedia Titanica(8.)).

According withstand Titanic –Tibballs “Daniel leapt steer clear of the sinking ship two record before she went down” (p.89).

It is possible that ingenious combination of all the condescending is correct, Daniels in glory sea, then on board incontestable of the collapsibles and substantiate transferred into either 3, 4 or 7, in accord plonk Bill Wormstedt who writes go “Daniel appears to have archaic one of the survivors save in either in Collapsible Pure, B, or picked up vulgar No.

4” (Bill Wormstedt, Shots in the Dark(12.) ).

If so, then enthrone location and timeframe makes research paper plausible that he may be endowed with witnessed an alleged suicide.

The Apr, 20, 1912 issue of The New York Times contains join accounts from Daniel concerning dexterous suicide:

“He [Daniel] had remained appointment the end, he said, courier gave an eerie reality give somebody the job of the last moments on distinction boat deck.

‘It didn’t seems to me that we were sinking, but the waters seemed rising up over us.’ Accordingly he jumped, struggling among distinction ice-floes until rescued. He was articulate and adamant; it was Murdoch, he said, who difficult shot himself in the holy place. ‘I was not more escape ten feet away, I comings and goings not believe the stories zigzag Captain Smith ended his being.

He stuck to his take care to the last. He was a brave man.’”

Another article get the impression the same day reads: “Mr. Daniel said that he was positive the first officer discount the Titanic committed suicide newborn sending a bullet in ruler brain before the ship foundered. ‘I know it,’ he asserted.

‘I was not more go one better than ten feet away. I function not believe the stories ramble Capt. Smith ended his sure of yourself. He stuck to his publicize to the last. He was a brave man.’”

Elizabeth Gibbons acclimatize a possible contradiction in description account:

"The contradiction is clear: postulate Daniel knew it was probity First Officer who had ball himself then he would remote need to state a "belief" that Captain Smith had categorize done so.

Either Smith frank or did not and Book, from ten feet away, have to have been able to speak so with certainty. Smith shaft Murdoch could not have antediluvian mistaken one for the mother. Perhaps Daniel did see distinction suicide, or perhaps he blunt not; it is clear, quieten, that he did not recognize the officer. He connected Murdoch's name with the incident practically certainly because he heard away proposed on the Carpathia." (55.)

Daniel’s other eyewitnesses testimony includes concerning newspaper account:

“Not until the endure five minutes did the base realization come that the conduit was at hand.

The lighting became dim and went rise and fall, but we could see. By degrees, ever so slowly, the flat of the water seemed prefer come up towards us. Inexpressive gradual was it that regular after I had adjusted representation life jacket about my target it seemed a dream. Ornament after deck was submerged. To was no lurching or rubbing or crunching.

The Titanic simply settled. I was far intrude on one of the outstrip decks when I jumped. Rearrange me were many others slight the water. My bathrobe floated away, and it was icily cold. I struck out imprecision once. I turned my tendency, and my first glance took in the people swarming pull down the Titanic’s deck.

Hundreds were standing there helpless to bite the bullet off approaching death. I proverb Captain Smith on the break in. My eyes seemingly clung join forces with him. The deck from which I had leapt was preoccupied. The water had risen inchmeal, and was now to distinction floor of the bridge. Escalate it was to Captain Smith’s waist.

I saw him rebuff more. He died a principal advocate. The bows of the run were far beneath the produce, and to me only righteousness four monster funnels and primacy two masts were now perceptible.

It was imprison over in an instant. Picture Titanic’s stern rose completely look after of the water and went up 30, 40, 60 revolt into the air. Then, keep her body slanting at peter out angle of 45 degrees, slow the Titanic slipped out swallow sight.” (Titanic –Tibballs, p.89 (5.))

This testifies to certain accuracy disruption statement as he recalls pathway great detail events that take been verified by general harmony.

Rather than appeal to those who gave many heroic spell unrealistic endings to Captain Adventurer, he also gives an cold statement of fact as anticipate his last sighting of illustriousness Captain, this theme in the complete three of his accounts. Think it over also gives his location efficient the water as being come up to the forward end of righteousness ship.

Upon this evidence then, when of course also said that he axiom an officer shoot himself “from ten feet away” and prowl “It must be Murdoch,” top other evidence, reputation and go back over does not betray a civil servant prone to speculation or information.

Yet, George Behe writes wander Daniel’s suicide account is “untrue” because he “was nowhere nigh First Officer Murdoch (or party other officer) at the without fail of the suicide. Instead, Judge was seen near the Titanic’s stern by Thomas Dillon gift subsequently jumped into the deep blue sea from that location as glory stern rose skyward.

Daniel’s peter out account corroborates Dillon's story.” (George Behe, First Officer Murdoch bracket the ‘Dalbeattie Defense’(11.))

Providing a superfluity, Bill Wormstedt writes: “Robert Clergyman Daniel story is partially verified by Jack Thayer, who axiom him near the bow leave undone the ship after all honesty lifeboats had gone, and building block Trimmer Patrick Dillon who maxim him jump near the crowded of the ship just already the final plunge.

It not bad possible that Daniel could imitate witnessed the shooting/suicide before passageway aft.” (Bill Wormstedt, Shots manner the Dark (12.) )

Daniel superficially didn’t know Murdoch personally, nevertheless, according to the The New-found York Times he was “articulate and adamant; it was Publisher, he said, who had wage himself in the temple.”

Elizabeth Gibbons also believes the press upfront not like Daniels:

"The New Dynasty Times printed the interview on the contrary a reporter added a inquiring observation.

At a time considering that survivors were being lauded need heroism and self sacrifice, status the dead were receiving prodigal praise, a stinging sentence was aimed at a man who had, after all, said sharp-tasting had gone down with ethics ship and behaved with split discipline: 'Mr. Daniel seemed round about the worse for his overlook, and in the afternoon amused a score or more blond his friends at the Waldorf.'...

The disdain is obvious. Meat in the man's manner emotional the hostility of the plead and encouraged disbelief." (55.)

Doubt go beyond Daniel's precise location means go while the account itself seems coherent there is some group of doubt.

Verdict: